QUOTE (Grasshopper @ Sep 22 2009, 09:15 AM)

Although I'm a little puzzled to the reference to 'readers'.
Once again my haste trips me up, LOL

I use HDD reading tools to repair computers/HDD's and have a few different kinds ie; IDE & SATA or mixed readers that plug in via USB & this drive wouldn't power up using any of these tools which is how I discovered the DOA HDD. Like you said Grasshopper, very unlucky as I swapped the PSU for a new one, spent ages looking for SATA controller issues in the BIOS (as some Advent laptops require this) prior to finding out the issue was DOA
There's no need to use seatools to prepare a SATA drive as XP formats the HDD on installation & creates NTFS on the drive for you. It's only a 160gb HDD and there's no need for partitions but having read back over this I may create a storage partition for data in case anything happens again!
thanks again guys